Recipe: Best Ever Apple Pie (and recipe for a double pie crust)

I am a member of the Collective Bias®  Social Fabric® Community.  This shop has been compensated as part of a social shopper insights study for Collective Bias®  and their client. #MyMarianos

Recipe: Best Ever Apple Pie & Double Pie Crust #MyMarianos #shop
Apple pie.

Every year we pay a visit to an apple orchard in Indiana and pick apples to bring home and use to create the most amazing apple pie. But this year, with everything that’s going on with David’s health, traveling far away from home to pick apples isn’t an option.

So instead, we did the next best thing. We headed to my favorite grocery store, Mariano’s, to pick fresh apples that ended up being perfect in our pie. Mariano’s actually has a huge assortment of apples to choose from, and finding the right ones to use for the pie was easy. I carefully selected the apples I needed for the recipe along with several more items on my grocery list. Then I looked through my purse for my Mariano’s rewards card and headed for the checkout lane.

Recipe for Apple Pie and Double Pie Crust #MyMarianos #shop

I always love shopping at Mariano’s because it’s more than just a grocery store. It’s an experience, and I can’t think of a better place to snag fresh apples (outside of an orchard) than Mariano’s. :)

Double Pie Crust
With any pie, you need to have a great crust, and the recipe I’m sharing for a double pie crust (since you need a top & bottom crust for an apple pie) is delicious! This crust has just the right balance of crunch around the edges, softness on the bottom, and sweetness, since we’re using it for an apple pie.

This is my go-to crust.

Recipe: Double Pie Crust - Perfect for Pies, especially apple pies! #MyMarianos #shopHere’s the recipe:

Double Pie Crust


  • 2-1/2 cups flour
  • 2-1/2 tablespoons sugar
  • 1 teaspoon fine sea salt
  • 8 tablespoons vegetable shortening, chilled
  • 12 tablespoons unsalted butter, chilled and cut into 1-inch pieces
  • 5-6 tablespoons ice water


  1. In a large bowl, whisk together the flour, sugar, and sea salt.
  2. Scatter the vegetable shortening over the flour mixture and using either two butter knives or your hands, incorporate the shortening. Afterwards, the mixture will resemble coarse sand.
  3. Scatter the butter over the coarse flour mixture using the same method you used with the vegetable shortening. (I actually used a combination of both methods for incorporating the butter.)
  4. Sprinkle ice water over the dough one tablespoon at a time. Press the dough together with a spatula after each tablespoon. Stop adding ice water once the dough has come together.
  5. Divide the dough evenly, so that it's in two pieces. Then flatten the dough and shape it into disks. Wrap the dough disks tightly with plastic wrap, and refrigerate them for 1 hour.
  6. When you're ready to use the dough, remove it from the refrigerator and let it sit for approximately 10 minutes, so that it softens and is easier to roll out.

Best Ever Apple Pie
I won’t make you wait any longer.

Recipe: Best Ever Apple Pie & Recipe for a Double Pie Crust #MyMarianos #shopHere’s the recipe for the best ever apple pie:

Best Ever Apple Pie


  • 3 large Granny Smith apples, peeled and cored
  • 3 large Cortland or McIntosh apples, peeled and cored
  • 3/4 cup plus 1 tablespoon granulated sugar
  • 1 tablespoon light brown sugar
  • 2 tablespoons flour
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1/4 teaspoon fine sea salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon nutmeg
  • 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
  • 1 egg white, lightly beaten
  • 1 Double Pie Crust (see recipe above)


  1. Adjust an oven rack to the lowest position and place a rimmed baking sheet on the rack. Heat the oven to 500 degrees.
  2. In a large bowl, toss the apples with 3/4 cup sugar, brown sugar, flour, lemon juice, sea salt, nutmeg, and cinnamon. Set mixture aside, and prepare to roll out the double pie crust.
  3. Roll out the double pie crust on a floured surface then place the bottom crust in the pie pan.
  4. Pour the apples onto the unbaked bottom crust. Make sure the apples create a mound shape in the pie crust.
  5. Lay the top crust over the apples, then seal and crimp the edges of the crust using either your fingers or a fork.
  6. Cut 4-5 vent holes in the top of the pie crust.
  7. Brush the top crust with the beaten egg white, and then sprinkle the remaining tablespoon of sugar over the crust.
  8. Carefully place the pie on the hot baking sheet in the oven then reduce the temperature to 425 degrees. Bake at this temperature until the top crust is golden brown. This should take 20-25 minutes. (I like to set a timer for 20 minutes and check at that point.)
  9. Once the top is golden brown, rotate the baking sheet, and turn the temperature down to 375 degrees. Bake another 30-35 minutes, until the top crust is a deep golden brown and the apple juices are bubbling.
  10. Remove the pie from the oven and allow it to cool before serving.

Perfect for the Holidays or Any Day
This apple pie pairs well with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream, and it would be perfect to enjoy for Thanksgiving or any old day of the week. :)

Recipe for Apple Pie & Double Pie Crust #MyMarianos #shop #dessert

What’s your favorite apple recipe? What’s one of your family’s favorite Fall recipes?

More on Mariano’s

As I eluded to in my post, Mariano’s is pretty awesome. They’re so awesome that they actually had an Opera Flash Mob surprise their customers as they shopped. You can see their reaction in the video below:

Also, you can find even more great recipes and ideas from the Mariano’s Community. And you can follow Mariano’s on Facebook and Twitter for their latest updates. #MyMarianos

Print Friendly
Share on Yummly

75 Responses to “Recipe: Best Ever Apple Pie (and recipe for a double pie crust)”

Read below or add a comment...

  1. Shelly says:

    I don’t make apple pie often, we usually have berry when I make a pie. Your looks so good you have me wanting to make an apple pie. :) At our house our favorite apple recipe is apple crisp, I use my grandma’s recipe.

  2. Alicia says:

    I’m reading this at 10pm on a Monday night…’s very, very cruel:) There is no chance for me to have apple pie for at least 12 hours:) #client

  3. Alex D says:

    This pie looks amazing! Last time I made apple pie it definitely didn’t look/taste like yours, and the apples were absolutely terrible lol, I will try this recipe though :)

  4. Looks amazing! Beautiful job!

  5. Zach J says:

    This is amazing! After work, I think I may just have to go home and make an apple pie!

  6. Dawn Lopez says:

    Oh my, your pie looks fantabulous! My mouth is totally watering right now. I am not very good at making pie.. but I am more than tempted to try your recipe!

  7. Emma T says:

    Hi Sandra,
    The pie really does look delicious, I’m definitely a sucker for sweet pies (apple or otherwise!) but would generally have custard with it, or cream.

    I have to admit, I’m lazy and would use ready made pastry, but we do get apples off our trees, so I can be allowed that sometimes!

    My favourite go to apple recipe is apple and blackberry crumble, both fruits picked off our trees or the hedgerows on the farm. It’s so quick and simple, and I tend to make more crumble topping base than needed and freeze it, so it’s even quicker.


    • Sandra says:

      The apple and blackberry crumble sounds so delicious, Emma! I’ll have to look for a recipe similar to what you mentioned. :)

  8. Amanda says:

    I am so curious…. why the baking sheet on the bottom rack? I’ve been making apple pies for ages for family holidays and am just now seeing this added “step” on MANY recipes. Can you offer any insight? Also, what does rotating the baking sheet do? I can’t wait to try these recipes for the holidays though!! :)

  9. Jackie M. says:

    I’ve made a lot of apple pies in my day, but I followed your recipe (pretty much) exactly and I have to say that the pie “goop” tasted awesome – it’s in the oven now, and I think it’s gonna be the star of the Thanksgiving table! Thanks for the baking times/temp changes – that’s really making for a beautiful pie! YAY! I am Spartacus!

  10. Sheila says:

    Anyone having problems with the pie crust? I followed instructions but when it’s time to roll dough it
    is just to soft, can’t pick it up to put in pie dish! Sandra any suggestion!!!!

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Sheila,

      I would try flouring the counter top again and rolling it out all over. Or simply put in back into the refrigerator for another 30 minutes or so. Sorry I couldn’t answer your question sooner! I hope you and your family have a wonderful Thanksgiving! :)

      • Bill Gabbard says:

        Most of the time for me it helps rolling the crust back onto the rolling pin and then putting it in pie pan, that way you don’t have to use your hands to pick it up

  11. Lori W says:

    This recipe is incredible…..I made it for Halloween and again for Thanksgiving dinner and it got rave reviews from everyone. The pie crust is so flaky and delicious….and the apple filling is to die for. Take the time to make it… won’t be disappointed!

  12. Jessica says:

    Hi Sandra thank you for posting this amazing pie recipe. I am embarrassed to ask this but i have to, Im going to be baking four pies for xmas and i wont have the time to make the crust. Is there a premade crust i can buy close to yours? These will also be the first pies i have ever made. EEK please help

  13. lucia says:

    Really yummy!!!! Thoroughly enjoyed it and so did the family!

    • Sandra says:

      Yay! Thanks for stopping by and letting me know how the pie turned out, Lucia! :) I’m so glad that you and your family enjoyed it!

  14. Diana says:

    this is sooooooooo good i made it and loved it i just used 5 apples i like it like that .. but i like to say THANK U for sharing it so i can try it mmmmmmm

  15. Brad says:

    I will definitely try this recipes, but I’m going to use Jonagold apples instead. I like the way they taste, so I hope it comes out as good as yours looks. I am also trying your crust, as mine seems to comer out too dryand yours sounds like it will be more tender. Thanks.

  16. Jill says:

    I made the pie and it looks relish! Question though – I really don’t want to bake it until tomorrow….how would you recommend storing it?

  17. Monica Chaffin says:

    I am going to make this today, I don’t like pie crust. Prob because I have used the roll out kind for many years for ease. SO I am going home made and making this today. I don’t usually like tons of pie crust (don’t like the taste) so I ususlly do a dutch apple pie, but it looks yummy so gonna do the two crust. We shall see

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Monica! I hope your pie turned out fabulously! :) I made this pie again last week, and it was gone in less than 24 hours. Lol

      I hope you have a great week!

  18. rebecca says:

    MMMM! Making this for my boyfriends birthday (tomorrow). I would like to get a head start and make crust tonight. Sandra, do you think I can freeze the crust overnight and still get the same result? Thanks in advance!

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Rebecca! I recommend making the crust today, wrapping it in plastic wrap (instructions in the recipe), and just leaving them wrapped in the refrigerator until the next day when you’re ready to use them.

      That’s what I do. :) I’ll make the crust the day before, wrap it, and leave it until the next day. You do not need to roll the crust out until the day you actually make the pie.

      You could freeze the crust, but I would recommend just leaving it in the fridge, if you’re planning on making the pie the next day. :)

  19. Janesse Reserva says:

    This pie tastes so heavenly.. I don’t really crave for pies, but this made me want to make one.. Absolutely a must try and you’ll never want to make an apple pie differently.. Thank you for this..

  20. Elizabeth says:

    Hi Sandra!

    Your recipe sounds amazing! I am hoping to make it for my Thanksgiving dessert. I was wondering if I could do a lattice work top rather than the full dough top with this recipe. Do you think that would work out?

    Cheers and Happy Holidays!

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Elizabeth! Yes, a lattice crust would work great for the top of this apple pie. :) I hope you and your loved ones have a Happy Thanksgiving!

  21. Justine Y says:

    This pie just looks so gorgeous, all piled up high with filling… I would love to include it in a round up of pies on my blog next week!

  22. Taylor Griffin says:

    I wish you would have indicated what size pie plate to use, especially for the novice baker.
    Will assume its a 9″ size.

  23. Monica says:

    I found this recipe last night and I made 2 this morning for Thanksgiving. I really don’t know if we can wait for dessert… the aromas in our house right now are amazing!! I do believe I’ve found our new “family” recipe! Thank you!!

  24. Tara says:

    I made this today for Thanksgiving. I made the dough discs last night and kept them wrapped in the fridge. I followed the recipe exactly. It is SO GOOD. Best apple pie we’ve ever had. Also my first time making one, a total success! Delicious with vanilla ice cream.

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Tara! THANK YOU so much for coming back and sharing how your apple pie turned out. :) I’m so glad your family enjoys it as much as mine does!

      I hope you have a great week!

  25. Heather says:

    I am planning on making this tonight and then freezing it until ready to bake on Saturday. How would you adjust the baking time to bake from freezing? I cant wait to try this!

  26. Dianne says:

    Thank you so much for giving such easy to follow directions that I attempted this pie, it came out fantastic and I have made 4 in the last month! 2 are in the works right now, oh did I mention that I am 70 years young and this is my first ever. My husband is so grateful, Apple has always been his fav!

    • Sandra says:

      What a sweet comment, Dianne! I’m so glad you liked the recipe and that your husband is enjoying it, too! That makes me very happy to hear. :)

      I hope you and your family have a very Merry Christmas!

  27. lyndin says:

    This apple pie is amazing! My grandma who is 82 is the pickiest women ever and she loved this and she said it is on of the best apple pies she has ever had! So thank you for sharing this recipe and helping me impress her!:)

    • Sandra says:

      Woohoo! :) I’m so glad that you and your grandma enjoyed the pie, Lyndin! And thanks for coming back and leaving such an encouraging comment. I hope you have a great week!

  28. Lana says:

    Hello! Would you recommend reheating this before serving? If so, for how long and what temperature? I want to bring this to a dinner party and I’m not sure if I should just bake it before hand and then take it over, or if I can reheat it for a little bit in the oven at the party.

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Lana! While I’ve never reheated an entire whole pie just before serving it, I DO typically heat slices individually in the microwave for about 30 seconds just before serving. This happens when we have pie leftovers from the previous day.

      If you’re taking the pie to a dinner party, I recommend making it the same day – possibly that morning? – and then it’ll be good to go for the dinner party without doing any additional reheating. :) I hope this helps.

  29. Alicia says:

    I made this for the family yesterday and it was delicious! Thank you for the great recipe!

    • Sandra says:

      Yay! I’m so glad to hear that, Alicia! :) Thanks for stopping by and trying out this recipe. I hope you have a great week!

  30. Deidra says:

    Lady, I would kiss you on the mouth for this apple pie recipe! I’m not a huge baker, but on behalf of Pi day I made this apple pie. It was well worth the burn on my knuckle!!!

  31. Shirley says:

    My pie is in the oven right now, the smell that is coming from the oven has the whole house smelling like apple pie. The pie itself looks like you would find in the most expensive restaurants. Can’t wait until it cools and I can try it.

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Shirley! I hope your pie turned out great! :) Thank you so much for trying this recipe and stopping by my blog!

  32. amanda says:

    Why did my pie melt?? The edges are basically melted off?? I have made so many perfect pie and never this, do I need to freeze the pie briefly to baking??

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Amanda! I’m so sorry to hear that your pie melted. I’ve never experienced that happening with any pie I’ve made in the past, but maybe something was not quite right with one of the ingredients. I’m not sure. :(

      You do not have to freeze the apple pie before baking it, but the butter and shortening do need to be well-chilled before using them in this recipe.

  33. Gail says:

    is the apple pie watery when you cut into it? I know a lot of people add tapioca pudding in the recipe to make it a little thicker, what do you think?

    • Sandra says:

      Hi Gail! The apple pie has a nice consistency and mine isn’t watery as long as I’ve let it cool. I’ve never tried adding tapioca pudding to the recipe, and I don’t think this recipe needs it. :)

      • Gail says:

        Thank you so much Sandra for responding back so quickly ☺️ I can’t wait to try your recipe, the only thing that I’m afraid of 😳 is that will eat it all in one day 😂😂😂

  34. Gail says:

    Sandra, how can I follow you on Pinterest? I would love to see more recipes ☺️👍👍


  1. […] Apple Pie from The Sensible Mom […]

  2. […] from The Sensible Mom Posted in: Holiday, […]

  3. […] Recipe source: […]

  4. […] * If you are interested in the recipes I used here are the links…Perfect Pie Crust,  Best Ever Apple Pie […]

  5. […] Bake an Apple Pie. My grandma used to bake apple pies all the time and I remember slicing the apples, rolling out the […]

  6. […] Here is the recipe I used for the apple pie! […]

  7. […] (If you want to try it out, here is the recipe!) […]

Thanks so much for stopping by The Sensible Mom! Now join the conversation!